Embroidery vs screen print vs DTF

The same logo can look cheap or expensive depending on how it gets onto the garment. Here is how the three workhorse methods differ, and how to pick one for the piece, the art and the run.

4 min read

01 // how they work

Three ways to put a logo on a garment

  • Screen printInk pushed through a fine mesh screen onto the fabric, one screen per color. Soft, flat, very durable, and cheapest per piece at volume.
  • EmbroideryYour logo converted into a stitch file, then sewn in thread. Raised, textured and built to last. The default for hats.
  • DTF transferDirect to film: the design is printed onto a film with an adhesive, then heat pressed onto the garment. Full color with no per-color setup.

02 // when to pick which

Match the method to the piece and the run

Screen print is the volume method. Once screens are made, every extra shirt is quick and cheap, and the print lives as long as the garment. It suits bold, simple art in a few spot colors, large front and back hits, and tonal designs where the ink sits close to the fabric color. Every extra color adds a screen, so a six-color logo costs more to set up than a one-color one.

Embroidery is the premium method. A small chest logo or a front hit on a cap looks finished in a way ink rarely does, and thread will not crack or fade. It struggles with tiny text, hairline strokes and photographic gradients, and it is heavy across large areas, so keep it to chest marks, sleeves, caps and small details. It is also the method for per-piece names or initials.

DTF is the flexible method. It prints full color with no screens, so gradients, photos and many-color art cost the same as a one-color mark. It shines on small runs, one-offs and fast turnarounds. The print sits on the surface with a slightly smooth hand, so very large DTF areas feel heavier than a screen print on a soft tee.

03 // by garment

What we would usually reach for

  • Caps and dad hatsEmbroidery. A printed hat front rarely looks right.
  • Heavyweight hoodiesEmbroidery for a chest mark, screen print for a big back hit, DTF for a small run in full color.
  • Everyday teesScreen print at 24 and up. DTF below that, or when the art has many colors.
  • Jackets and outerwearEmbroidery or appliqué. Thicker fabrics take stitching well.
  • Tote bagsScreen print for runs, DTF for short or full-color runs.

04 // minimums and setup

What each one needs from you

At MerchHQ, screen print starts at 24 pieces, and below 24 we make the same design as a transfer. Embroidery starts at 1 piece, with digitizing done once per design. DTF starts at 1 and is pressed on our in-house heat press in our NYC office, which is why singles make sense.

Beyond the big three, we also do appliqué, tonal print, custom woven labels, letterpress, debossing and laser engraving, so the method can follow the look you want rather than the other way around.

  • Send vector art (SVG, AI or PDF) when you have it.
  • Name your brand colors as Pantone values for screen print and thread matching.
  • Simplify fine detail for embroidery: very small text does not hold up in thread.
  • Check the print size on the proof against the real garment, not just the mockup.

compare // side by side

Screen print vs DTF transfer

Screen printDTF transfer
SetupOne screen per colorNo per-color setup
MerchHQ minimum24 pieces1 piece
Best artBold shapes, a few spot colorsFull color, gradients, photos
FeelSoft, ink sits in the fabricSmooth layer that sits on the surface
Cost curveCheapest per piece at volumeFlat per piece; strongest at small runs
Best forTeam runs, events, big back printsOne-offs, short runs, rush

Embroidery is covered in the sections above. Minimums are MerchHQ's; everything else is general industry practice.

faq // straight answers

Questions we get

Which lasts longer, embroidery or screen print?
Both outlast most garments when done well. Embroidery will not crack or fade, and a properly cured screen print holds up for years of washing.
Is DTF as good as screen printing?
For small runs and full-color art, DTF is the better tool. For large runs of simple art, screen print is cheaper per piece and has a softer feel, which is why MerchHQ uses screen print from 24 pieces and transfers below that.
What is best for logos on hats?
Embroidery. It suits the curved, structured front of a cap and reads as finished. MerchHQ embroiders from 1 piece.
Why does my logo need digitizing for embroidery?
An embroidery machine sews from a stitch file, not an image. Digitizing turns your logo into that file once, and the same file is reused on later orders.
Can you embroider names on individual pieces?
Yes. MerchHQ offers per-piece names and initials in embroidery, which is how monthly birthday gifts with embroidered initials work.

access // onboarding, not a signup

Tell us what you’d run through MerchHQ.

We take on organizations one at a time and build the program in your brand. You approve once; we run design, production, payment and delivery.

Request access

hello@merchhq.comEmail us →

Every serious note gets a reply. Include your organization and what you want made.